Fee’s Kafkaesque Kroes response — EU tech coup — Style assertion – POLITICO

Press play to hearken to this text

A weekly e-newsletter on campaigning, lobbying and political affect within the EU.



Suggestions, tales, traumas to @swheaton or [email protected] | View in your browser

HOWDY. Welcome to your first August version (of a number of!) of EU Affect. Brussels’ European quarter is quiet as establishments shut down for the summer season — as do the eating places that serve their employees energy lunches and fast bites. We hope these eating spots use this day without work to come back into compliance with the foundations requiring digital funds. We discovered ourselves, as common, scrambling for paper payments and speeding to the ATM final month, regardless of the Belgian authorities’s July 1 deadline for accepting cashless compensation. It’s not unlawful, we suppose, to have a damaged bank card reader in perpetuity — a basic Belgian resolution all too many cafés appear to be embracing. 

We’ll be operating (virtually) each week in August, so maintain sending ideas and job strikes to [email protected] — and maintain us in thoughts while you’re caught in a protracted line on the airport. 


“​​I’ve interviewed each lobbyists and people being lobbied, and I believe one of many first issues I realized was that you simply by no means use the phrase lobbying in your introduction e-mail.”

— Emilia Korkea-aho, lobbying researcher and professor on the College of Japanese Finland, in an interview with Observe the Cash


NEWS FLASH: The European Fee simply rejected POLITICO’s freedom-of-information request for ex-Commissioner Neelie Kroes’ software to work for Uber earlier than the top of her cooling-off interval. 

Simply kidding, that’s not information. We’d have been stunned if our request had been granted. Nonetheless, we discover the rationale for the rejection to be — forgive the technical time period — weaksauce. 

First, a fast refresher: Kroes did certainly foyer for Uber shortly after her tenure because the EU’s digital commissioner, in line with a trove of emails that ex-Uber lobbyist Mark MacGann shared with the Worldwide Consortium of Investigative Journalists. The Fee has acknowledged that Kroes did ask permission, however withdrew her software after then-President Jean-Claude Juncker tipped her off that the Unbiased Moral Committee had given a thumbs-down. The Fee says they’re learning Kroes’ response to the allegations, however the entire mess highlights main enforcement gaps within the EU’s ethics guidelines. 

On Tuesday, the Fee formally rejected our request to see Kroes’ software. We’re nonetheless ready to listen to again in regards to the communication from Juncker to her.

The rationale: Releasing a withdrawn software “would divulge to the general public info and detailed exchanges on initially supposed post-mandate skilled actions which didn’t materialise following the withdrawal,” wrote the Fee’s Tatjana Verrier, to elucidate the denied paperwork request. 

Besides, uh, they did allegedly materialize. 

Verrier provides that requests withdrawn previous to the adoption of a call “are thought of to not have been lodged.” She provides, “In consequence, no additional observe up was given to them by the Fee.”

Besides, uh, Juncker appears to have adopted up. 

The letter additionally has loads of different stuff about defending a former commissioner’s privateness, in addition to defending the corporate — or the one that ended up with the position that the commissioner may need taken — from any embarrassment or reputational injury. We think about Uber is grateful for all these concerns by the EU government.

Fee’s burden: In consequence, it’s the EU government risking the reputational hit. “Denying the general public the whole lot of the knowledge might skew residents’ view of ethics oversight at EU degree,” mentioned Transparency Worldwide EU’s Vitor Teixeira. It finally makes scandals “extra shocking” once they do come to gentle, he argued, “and finally degrades the belief put in establishments to guard the general public curiosity.” 

Recognized unknowns: Korkea-aho, the lobbying researcher, made an identical level in her Observe the Cash interview. She’s learning the Fee’s selections about officers’ revolving door requests, and he or she famous that there’s by no means been public proof of the ethics committee reaching a adverse determination. Is that as a result of they’re a rubber-stamp, or as a result of individuals at all times withdraw their functions earlier than the opinion will get revealed? Who is aware of!

“The Fee would look quite a bit harder if in between all these optimistic opinions there would generally be a adverse opinion,” Korkea-aho famous. 

THAT OTHER REVOLVING DOOR SCANDAL: Former German Chancellor Gerhard Schröder admitted he was assembly with Russian President Vladimir Putin final week in Moscow. (He initially claimed to be on a Russian vacation.) Schröder urged Germany to rethink its rejection of Nord Stream 2. 



An nameless lobbyist for a significant meals producer rocked this (considerably ironic) style assertion at The Good Foyer Summer time Academy final month. 


RENTRÉE ROUNDTABLE ON STANDARDS: The Fee is planning a gathering at a “technical degree” with the opposite EU establishments in September to hash out plans for an unbiased ethics physique, a spokesperson informed EU Affect. 

It’s an indication of incremental progress on an overarching committee that will apply widespread moral requirements throughout establishments. Whereas the Uber Information may need added a little bit of strain, a peek on the suggestions the Fee acquired from different EU establishments exhibits tepid assent, at finest.

You first: The Fee will clearly have to guide the dialogue, regardless that its personal suggestions to Parliament confirmed loads of misgivings and weariness of the problems of making use of a standard normal with out compromising the separation of powers. 

We’ve obtained a lot of the replies. Right here’s our TL;DR:

—  Council of the EU: Ethics and transparency are nice. However capitals “share the Fee’s view” that the ethics physique would contact on “delicate points” and underline that its members are already topic to nationwide ethics guidelines. 

— European Court docket of Auditors: We are able to’t be a part of this, since we may be known as on to weigh in. But it surely’s an excellent concept for everybody else — the truth is we’ve prompt it, too — and we’re glad to share our concepts. Such a physique’s suggestions would supply a “helpful reference level” for the ECA.  

— Court docket of Justice of the European Union: We are able to’t be a part of this, since we may be known as on to weigh in, and we additionally can not undergo ethics supervision by an exterior physique “with out compromising the elemental precept of judicial independence.” However a standard understanding of how EU establishments fulfill moral obligations, “if made accessible, might undoubtedly present helpful steering” for our personal moral supervision. 

— Committee of the Areas: We’re sport! To speak, not less than…

— European Central Financial institution: We’re sport! To speak, not less than, however we already be ok with our seven-year-old ethics committee. Chief Compliance and Governance Officer Roman Schremser will probably be your level man. 


EU TECH COUP: When Brussels opens for enterprise once more in September, a well-recognized face may have modified roles, Pieter Haeck stories, boosting the lobbying energy of EU-based tech firms. 

SWITCHING SIDES: Victoria de Posson, at present prime coverage participant within the Brussels workplace of the Laptop & Communications Trade Affiliation (a D.C.-based foyer dominated by American tech giants), will tackle the newly-created position of secretary-general on the EU Tech Alliance (EUTA), in line with 4 individuals aware of the matter. 

Elevating the EU tech profile: Over the previous few years, European tech firms of all sizes (each established and stock-listed firms, like Spotify or Reserving.com, and smaller upstarts, like Again Market and Vinted) have joined forces within the EU Tech Alliance, ensuring their voices are heard in Brussels — which meant they primarly weighed in on the platform regulation debate, with the Digital Markets Act and Digital Providers Act

A everlasting place: Work on the EU Tech Alliance — which counts over 35 members after six years — was up till now taken up by “volunteering” executives from amongst its members.

With de Posson coming in as secretary-general (a emptiness that had been up for the reason that finish of March), EUTA may have a everlasting consultant in Brussels, which was described within the job advert as taking the alliance “to the following degree.”

AWKWARD TIMING: CCIA is dropping a key knowledgeable throughout the cash time in numerous information of curiosity, just like the implementation of the digital competitors and content material moderation rulebooks and the battle with Huge Telecoms over who ought to pay for infrastructure.

Study extra: This week’s EU Confidential Podcast, hosted by tech reporter Samuel Stolten, will probably be dedicated to the (doubtlessly hostile) battle over telecoms contributions. Subscribe to get Thursday’s episode as quickly because it’s out. 



— Adrian Garcia, a former strategist for Volt Europe and chief of the boutique consultancy Res Terrae, is becoming a member of Instinctif Companions as an account director.

Instinctif Companions has additionally employed Jakub Hodek as an account government, beforehand of TAS Europrojects.


— After a decade as Luxembourg’s ambassador to the EU, Georges Friden is heading to London to signify the Grand Duchy within the U.Ok., Luxemburger Wort stories.

Marika Put up, the spokesperson of the Estonian everlasting illustration, is shifting house after 9 years to be particular consultant/ambassador-at-large for Baltic Sea cooperation. Succeeding her is Triin Oppi, who till now has labored as head of communications on the Worldwide Heart for Defence and Safety.

Majlinda Dhuka is Albania’s new chief negotiator for EU accession, changing Zef Mazi, in line with Exit Information


Stefan Feltens, the president of the European Affiliation of E-Pharmacies, joins the Alliance for Secure On-line Pharmacy within the EU as a co-director. 

Anna Wurm heads to EIT Well being as a public affairs and stakeholder relations supervisor at EIT Well being, through Acumen Public Affairs.

Valerio Demontis is the new public affairs coordinator for the European Renal Affiliation


Alessandro Da Rold joins the cupboard of European Parliament Vice President Eva Kaili as a public affairs adviser, whereas holding on to his gig as head of EU40 — The Community of Younger MEPs. 


Guntram Wolff, former director of the Bruegel suppose tank, began as CEO and director on the German Council on Overseas Relations.

NOS EXCUSES: Final week’s e-newsletter mischaracterized the French Federation of Applied sciences’ acknowledged goal. FFTech goals to be a discussion board for French tech gamers in Brussels to mingle and get to know one another. 

THANKS TO: Pieter Haeck, Lili Bayer, and Peter O’Brien; internet producer Giulia Poloni and my editor Nicholas Vinocur.

SUBSCRIBE to the POLITICO e-newsletter household: Brussels Playbook | London Playbook | Playbook Paris | Politico Confidential | Sunday Crunch | EU Affect | London Affect | Digital Bridge | China Direct | Berlin Bulletin | D.C. Playbook | D.C. Affect | International Insider | All our POLITICO Professional coverage morning newsletters

Extra from …

Sarah Wheaton

Leave a Comment