China’s Migrant “Bosses” Face Exploitation In The Quick Trend Business


Nellie Chu is an assistant professor of anthropology at Duke Kunshan College, a partnership between Duke College and Wuhan College in Kunshan, China.

GUANGZHOU, China — As I walked by the slim alleyways of the garment district right here in China’s third-largest metropolis one afternoon, I noticed a lady I’ll name Wong Yip sitting beside a big worktable by the tall entrance gates of her manufacturing unit. In 2012, Wong Yip and her husband, who I’ll name Wong Zi, moved right here from neighboring Guangxi Province to experiment within the dangers and rewards of entrepreneurship. They personal and function their very own small-scale industrial workshop, colloquially often known as a jiagongchang, located in a garage-like den that facilitates the mass meeting of low-cost clothes certain for transnational merchants and finally exported as quick style to abroad markets across the globe. 

Along with her eyes solid downward, she took a stack of thick elastic bands and positioned them beside a ruler earlier than slicing them into slim strips. Piles of rigorously measured unfastened cloth strands gathered on the desk in entrance of her. I sat on a wood stool beside her and mentioned hiya. She returned a smile, nevertheless it regarded drained and compelled, seeming to cover a flood of emotion brewing inside her. After I informed her I had the following few days off from educating, she remarked how fantastic a scholarly life should be.

A lanky man in a white t-shirt and fitted khaki pants cropped proper above his ankles emerged out of the manufacturing unit and stood beside me. Wong regarded up at him and spoke angrily. “You have to perceive,” she mentioned, “it takes cash to pay for the electrical energy and to pay our staff. … We’ve been ready for over a month now and also you owe us greater than 10,000 RMB. We refuse at hand over the completed clothes till you pay us the cash!” 

The younger man stood nonetheless and silent in entrance of her. Apparently, his South Korean shopper was falling behind on his payments. Delays in assembly style deadlines and funds had left him in a spiral of debt and loss. Wong appeared to hardly care. “I’m going to name your kinfolk and your purchasers,” she yelled at him. “After I do, they higher give you the cash. In the event that they fail to pay, consider me, we’ll ship my husband on to your retailer. We’ll shut it down and demand a cost. We all know precisely the place you do enterprise. Don’t assume we’re not able to doing this!” When she lastly stopped her tirade, the younger man bowed his head a number of occasions, a gesture of apology and disgrace. 

After he departed, Wong turned to me. “I had my suspicions about them from the primary second I solid my eyes upon them,” she mentioned. She informed me they got here from Xi Fang Cling, the wholesale marketplace for low-cost clothes in Guangzhou that was notorious for shady enterprise. However they begged and pushed, Wong mentioned. Ultimately, as she put it, “They compelled us right into a working relationship.” 

I requested her if she and her husband actually would go to their retailer and demand the cash in the event that they nonetheless didn’t pay. “In fact!” she responded. The individuals who work at that market are recognized to be very aggressive, I warned her. Indignantly, she replied that she and her husband have been equally able to being pushy.

“In southern China, a discrete but unrecognized realm has opened the place migrants personal their very own factories, declare themselves ‘boss’ and luxuriate in restricted social and bodily mobility.”

Over the previous 20 years, there was an increase in scholarly critiques of quick style which have uncovered the darkish facet of manufacturing and consuming low-cost, designer-inspired clothes and equipment. These critiques continuously middle on the issues of local weather change, sweatshop labor, unethical knockoffs and cultural appropriation: the nefarious results of low-cost, disposable fashions attribute of post-Fordist, “simply in time” capitalism. 

My analysis focuses on the sides of that world: In southern China, a discrete but unrecognized realm has opened the place migrants personal their very own factories, declare themselves “boss” and luxuriate in restricted social and bodily mobility. Their so-called freedom, nevertheless, is characterised by rare and short-term successes, since their small-scale entrepreneurial actions feed into transnational outsourcing preparations that constantly exploit and extract their labor by unforgiving competitors and unpredictable work rhythms.

I name these experiences of small-scale migrant entrepreneurship “bosshood.” It illustrates one essential facet of quick style that usually will get elided from standard photographs and accounts of transnational “simply in time” commodity change. Quick style, and by extension transnational capitalism from the Nineties to right this moment, wouldn’t have flourished at a world scale with out the work of migrant subcontractors who’ve taken on precarious dwelling and laboring circumstances. 

These experiences go away them hovering in an ambiguous and ambivalent area someplace between the sweatshop laborer and the globe-trotting entrepreneur — just like what the anthropologist Aihwa Ong calls the “astronaut,” a official entrepreneur who shows his wealth by shuttling between his enterprise actions in Hong Kong or China and his household in different elements of the globe. Inside this in-between area, the migrant laoban (boss) hyperlinks post-socialist city transformations in China to the transnational provide chains of quick style. 

The Rise Of The Migrant Boss

Alongside the hidden corridors and slim alleyways of Guangzhou’s garment district, clusters of jiagongchang serve the transnational provide chains for fast-fashion manufacturing and change. Right here, market members assemble, contest and negotiate the spatial and temporal boundaries of low-cost, designer-inspired fashions as they remodel uncooked supplies and on a regular basis objects into the most recent kinds and traits. This household-based mannequin of mass manufacture in Guangzhou makes use of easy second-hand machines to compete with the performance-driven and superior applied sciences of fast-fashion manufacturing in bigger Fordist-type factories in southern China. 

In line with the hukou, a coverage of inhabitants management left over from the Maoist interval, migrant jiagongchang staff are members of the liudong renkou (floating inhabitants), a gaggle whose authorized standing excludes them from vital state advantages within the cities they’ve migrated to, together with housing, training, healthcare and employment. These exclusions bind them to low-paying jobs with oppressive labor circumstances within the manufacturing and repair industries, thereby creating one of many world’s largest swimming pools of exploitable low-wage labor. On the similar time, their participation in international provide chains for quick style fuels their needs for private autonomy through entrepreneurship and self-employment.

“Simply in time” subcontracted manufacturing lowers manufacturing prices for middleman wholesalers and retailers whereas offsetting the related dangers of environmental air pollution, labor disputes, accidents, capital flight and chapter to different members throughout the chain. Such strategies of temporal and corporeal administration separate manufacturing websites throughout international provide chains so that every jiagongchang turns into a specialised node in a wider community. The fragmentation of those websites allows migrants to float from one jiagongchang to a different, whereas those that have sufficient financial savings to personal and function their very own can experiment with the dangers and rewards of self-enterprise.

“Migrant jiagongchang staff are excluded from vital state advantages together with housing, training, healthcare and employment.”

In impact, many migrant bosses, together with the momentary staff they rent, paradoxically describe their labor as “free” regardless of lengthy hours, low wages and precarious working circumstances. Day by day, they encounter the folks, photographs and objects of worldly fashions. Standing within the shadows of bigger factories, many think about themselves as socially cellular. Few know exactly the place the commodities they produce find yourself, and they’d be unable to journey there even when they did. However their encounters with materials and colours and kinds on the store ground gasoline a curiosity and need to discover the world. 

On the similar time, nevertheless, they need to negotiate the dangers and contradictions related to the circumstances of their immobility and displacement. Many staff, particularly feminine sewers organized alongside the meeting traces of garment mass manufacture, can solely think about the wholesale markets the place the clothes are bought and the comparatively well-to-do shoppers who purchase them. They’re caught of their nodes on the provision chain, certain by the uneven rhythms of fast-fashion manufacturing, in a position solely to collaborate and negotiate with different migrant laborers and purchasers as dictated by the calls for of transnational outsourcing. 

On a regular basis Uncertainties In The Jiagongchang

The Wongs’ enterprise has introduced them a restricted sense of non-public autonomy. However they notice they’ve minimal management over the timing of the manufacturing processes. Unforgiving deadlines, intensified by the fast turnover of style kinds, confine each employers and staff to their stitching stations on the manufacturing unit ground. 

I’ve usually seen each Wongs labor alongside their staff for hours in the course of the day and evening, at the same time as they juggle different duties like coordinating supplies, staff and machines. Conflicts between employers and staff usually come up straight by failures of the manufacturing course of itself, which happen when machines halt, supplies go lacking or staff speak again or refuse to work. 

When manufacturing is at full scale, the tempo of labor is troublesome to manage. That is significantly the case when the Wongs’ purchasers are middleman brokers for abroad wholesalers. These brokers usually alter manufacturing particulars — positioning of logos, tags, printing inventory numbers, including or eliminating gildings and equipment, altering materials and supplies — in keeping with the whims of their fickle purchasers. These particulars can upend the tempo and circumstances of labor for the Wongs and their staff. 

Earlier than the beginning of the pandemic, the Wongs sometimes obtained orders from walk-in purchasers, a lot of whom occurred to encounter the manufacturing unit. These purchasers would normally have an association for uncooked supplies and materials with their wholesale purchasers in place and would coordinate supply to the Wongs’ manufacturing unit. The Wongs would then assemble their work groups primarily based on the variety of fingers wanted per order. 

Generally this necessitated calls to household and mates. Wong Zi’s older brother operates a bigger garment manufacturing unit within the neighborhood, so he would ship staff over if he can spare them. One other brother is an ironer close by, and typically he and his spouse would assist. Up to now, Wong Yip has invited household mates from her house village in Guangxi to reside and work with the couple for a number of months at a time. There was a small chalkboard that hung by the entrance gate of their manufacturing unit the place Wong Yip posts hiring notices. Different occasions, she would stroll over a close-by pedestrian bridge to an space the place unemployed staff collect to search for momentary work. 

“Quick style wouldn’t have flourished at a world scale with out the work of migrant subcontractors who’ve taken on precarious dwelling and laboring circumstances.”

Final-minute orders typically arrive within the late afternoon, sending staff scrambling to finish their duties. Durations of sustained depth are damaged by lengthy intervals of ready or unemployment. Surprising idleness turns into a supply of monetary concern. As soon as, throughout a quiet week between orders, I urged to Wong Yip that she compensate for sleep. “You don’t know what it’s like in our line of labor,” she responded. “We will’t take breaks as a result of we don’t know the place our cash will come from.” 

Steadily, Wong Zi joins his staff at a shopper’s bigger manufacturing unit to finish a job or redo a botched order. Wong Yip, in the meantime, will spend most of her working day laboring alongside her staff on the manufacturing unit ground. She’s going to leap up and assume the function of a supervisor when walk-in purchasers enter the manufacturing unit to debate an order. Disagreements together with her staff over the standard of their work can come up, resulting in arguments and departures. Equally, Wong Yip will typically need to battle these additional up the provision chain over missed deadlines and garment high quality. 

The delicate coordination of purchasers, staff and uncooked supplies types the boundaries to the Wongs’ autonomy. As bosses of their labor and technique of manufacturing, they’re not topic to the fixed surveillance and managerial management of bigger factories. But the uneven temporal pulses and makeshift manufacturing unit areas attribute of quick and versatile manufacturing of low-cost clothes intensify the extraction of labor, whereas making a surplus of accessible staff when the tempo of market exercise slackens. 

Regardless that the Wongs discuss with themselves as bosses, I usually see them working alongside their employed staff a minimum of 10-12 hours a day. They’re continuously deserted by purchasers who owe them cash. Employees will storm off the manufacturing unit ground in the midst of a manufacturing order once they disagree with the phrases of their momentary employment. After I ask the couple about their plans for his or her future, they merely say, “We don’t know. Subsequent 12 months, we could also be right here. Perhaps not. We simply don’t know the way the market might be.”

Worldy Aspirations, Unsure Bosshoods

The pandemic introduced new uncertainties. A number of opponents within the garment district closed their companies, however the Wongs have managed to outlive by dwelling on marginal income. To economize, they moved their manufacturing unit to an space the place rents are cheaper. However visiting it just lately, I believed it could make them much more remoted and precarious than earlier than. 

On a busy road lined with house complexes and grocery shops, their new workshop is on the second ground of a dilapidated concrete constructing. It occupies your complete ground — loads of area, however darkish and musty. Solely a single window that overlooks the rooftop of an adjoining constructing permits in a fragile ray of daylight. 

Instantly beneath the window, a small grocery retailer blasts a piercing recording of a person saying the offers of the day in an limitless loop. Reverse the wall with the small window are the stitching machines. Their youthful son sat at a workstation, head down, working diligently on an order of brightly coloured fuchsia clothes. In a nook, the Wongs had arrange a twin-sized mattress for themselves. Simply subsequent to it was the range and toilet the place they cooked, bathed and washed their garments. 

As I walked in, Wong Zi was cooking on the range — stir-fried greens, black bean fish, Hainanese hen. I regarded round. Distinguished, white, Roman-style columns graced the again wall subsequent to the son’s stitching station. Ragged items of white and pink lace hung from the low ceiling, swaying in entrance of an air-con unit. I spotted that the area had previously served as a bridal images studio, which probably had fallen sufferer to the financial downturn introduced by COVID-19. 

We sat down for lunch. The Wongs have been within the means of ending up an order for an agent who lived abroad and dealt with orders solely for African markets. The clothes strewn throughout the dingy concrete ground have been certain for a Congolese shopper. Wong Zi lamented that they may not depend on walk-in purchasers, a vital supply of earnings and casual advertising at their former workshop. Purchasing journeys for material and equipment or searches for momentary staff had grow to be longer now that they have been outdoors the garment district. 

“To me, the Wongs appeared caught in an limitless situation of stalled mobility.”

They appeared ambivalent about their new challenges. New orders have been nonetheless coming in, preserving them afloat. Most have been for African markets, which meant that their revenue margins have been exceedingly low, primarily due to exorbitant transport prices amid the pandemic, in addition to the various intermediaries throughout the provision chains by which the commodities handed. 

Within the early years of their operation, the Wongs targeted on abroad slightly than home orders. However the disruptions to the world’s fast-fashion provide chains attributable to the pandemic made orders from distant purchasers rather more troublesome. With the Chinese language border successfully closed, and with the presence of foreigners in Guangzhou’s style markets shrinking, most of the Wongs’ opponents turned to home purchasers to outlive financially. 

Some had the manpower and assets to fabricate clothes extraordinarily shortly, thus assembly the wants of “simply in time” deliveries. Others, nevertheless, had no alternative however to tackle the dangers of being exploited by home purchasers, who demanded quicker turnaround time for deliveries at even decrease prices. The Wongs refused, hoping the abroad markets would flip round. 

To me, they appeared caught in an limitless situation of stalled mobility. Their income have been fractions of what that they had been earlier than the pandemic. However they have been hanging on, hoping for the extra profitable orders from Japan, South Korea and the U.S. to return after the worldwide financial system recovers. Within the meantime, they have been exhausting themselves working longer hours with fewer staff. 

“Staying on the treadmill of lengthy hours for little pay within the hopes of stepping up the social ladder meant greater than any financial returns.”

As I used to be leaving the manufacturing unit, I urged to Wong Yip that we may maybe see one another once more later within the week, at occasions when she wanted to purchase groceries or exit for walks. She regretfully admitted that she hardly went out for walks since that they had moved into their new workshop. Tight deadlines and lengthy hours made it troublesome for her to schedule a gathering upfront. I sensed a level of loneliness and isolation in her voice. “Meet us once more in Guangzhou or in Guigang [their hometown],” she mentioned. “You might be household to us now. We could also be aside, however in our hearts, you’re our household!” 

Guigang is a metropolis of maybe 4 million folks a few hours west of Guangzhou. If the Wongs are compelled to shut their manufacturing unit and return there, their aspirations for worldliness, monetary safety, social mobility and entrepreneurship would finish. Again in Guigang, they must return to low-paying wage work in bigger factories run by extra highly effective and exploitative folks. They’d not be their very own bosses. 

Laboring in Guangzhou’s delipidated industrial zone paradoxically facilitated a platform for the Wongs to increase their productive capacities to international markets. As bosses of a node in a world community of style merchandise, they have been related to a world past the attain of many Chinese language. And but, their very participation within the transnational provide chain left them remoted and extra unsure about their future than earlier than. 

For them, staying on the treadmill of lengthy hours for little pay within the hopes of stepping up the social ladder from migrants towards prospects outdoors China’s borders meant greater than any financial returns. Just like the fuchsia clothes certain for the wholesale markets in West Africa, they aspired to maneuver up the provision chain, to hunt greater revenue margins and greater purchasers. However fulfilling these goals relied on financial and political forces that remained totally outdoors their management. 

Leave a Comment